Online Doctor在线问诊
In-Home Care居家护理
Body Check深度体检 Weight Loss体重管理 For Employers企业方案
Wellness Studio康伴智疗坊
Blog健康资讯 905‑305‑3107905‑305‑3107 Members: Book a visit会员预约
Nutrition营养饮食

Is More Protein Always Better? What 350+ Studies Say 蛋白质越多越好吗?350+ 项研究告诉你真相

CarebyRachel LRachel L August 11, 20262026年8月11日 6 min read阅读约 6 分钟

When you're stocking up at Costco or Loblaws, do you automatically reach for a giant tub of protein powder or a box of high-protein bars? At home, do you keep telling your parents or your kids to eat one more egg — thinking the more protein they get, the stronger they'll be? 去 Costco 或者 Loblaws 囤货的时候,你是不是也习惯顺手搬两桶大蛋白粉,或者扛一箱高蛋白能量棒回家?平时在家里,也总忍不住劝爸妈、劝娃多吃个蛋,或者顿顿做鸡胸肉,总觉得"多补点蛋白质,身体肯定更结实"。

If you're not moving much, those expensive tubs and daily chicken breasts may be doing less for you than you think. 但说实话,如果平时动得少,这些高价买回来的蛋白粉和顿顿鸡胸肉,可能只是在给身体帮倒忙。

The short answer先说结论
  • More protein is not always better. Without enough exercise, your body can't turn the extra into muscle — it becomes a metabolic load instead.蛋白质真不是吃得越多越好。如果没有足够的运动量,身体根本没办法把多出来的蛋白质转化成肌肉,最后反倒成了代谢负担。
  • How much you need depends on how much you move — not on what's trending.每天到底该吃多少蛋白质,得看你动了多少,而不是盲目跟风。
  • A healthy adult baseline is about 0.8 g of protein per kilogram of body weight per day. People doing regular strength training generally need more — around 1.2 to 1.6 g/kg.普通健康成年人,每天大约每公斤体重 0.8 克蛋白质就够了;经常做力量训练的人通常需要更多,约每公斤体重 1.2 到 1.6 克。
  • Rather than weighing every meal, a routine check-up can show you whether your body is actually overloaded.与其天天拿着食物秤斤斤计较,不如定期体检,几个关键指标就能看出身体有没有超载。

A recent review in a Cell sister journal pulled together more than 350 animal and human studies and reached a conclusion that surprised a lot of people: moderately restricting protein intake appears to be better for metabolism, cell repair and slowing aging. 《细胞》(Cell)子刊前阵子汇总了 350 多项针对动物和人类的研究,结论挺颠覆认知的:适当少吃点蛋白质,反而对改善新陈代谢、促进细胞修复和延缓衰老更有好处。

The mechanism behind it is a hormone called FGF21 (fibroblast growth factor 21), which rises when protein intake is moderately reduced. The review makes a point worth remembering: if you spend most of your day sitting at a computer, your body simply doesn't need that much raw material. Eating more of it is just extra work for your system. 这背后的关键,在于适度控制蛋白质摄入能提高体内一种叫 FGF21(成纤维细胞生长因子 21)的激素水平。研究特别强调,如果你每天大部分时间都在电脑前坐着,身体根本不需要那么多"原料",吃多了反而是负担。

How much you move decides how much you need每天动多少,决定了你该怎么吃

There is no one-size-fits-all protein formula. What belongs on your plate depends on how active you actually are. 每个人每天的活动量不一样,餐盘里的蛋白质分量自然也得跟着变,根本没有一个包治百病的万能公式。

If you sit most of the day: extra protein becomes belly fat, not muscle每天坐着不怎么动:多吃不仅不长肌肉,还容易长肚子

If you're like most office workers — hours in front of a screen, a drive to work, and the couch at the end of it — your body's demand for cell repair is low. 如果你和大多数上班族一样,每天在电脑前一坐就是好几个小时,通勤靠开车,回家累得只想陷在沙发里,基本没什么规律运动,身体对细胞修复的需求量其实非常小。

Adding extra eggs and steak "for your health" without any strength training to stimulate muscle growth doesn't build muscle. Those calories settle around your waist instead. And if your kidney function is already borderline, a steady surplus of protein waste is extra work your kidneys don't need. 这时候要是为了"健康"强行多吃蛋、多吃肉,又没有力量训练去刺激肌肉生长,多出来的热量根本变不成肌肉,只会变成肚子上的游泳圈。而且,对于肾功能本来就一般的人来说,一堆代谢不掉的蛋白质在体内堆积,真的是在给肾脏找麻烦。

If you train: three scoops a day may already be too much健身狂热分子:一天三勺蛋白粉,可能早就超标了

People who lift regularly do need more protein — usually around 1.2 to 1.6 grams per kilogram of body weight. But it's easy to overshoot: a shake at every meal on top of large portions of meat goes well past what the body can use. 经常做力量训练的人,确实需要比普通人补充更多蛋白质,通常建议是每公斤体重吃 1.2 到 1.6 克。但现在很多健身爱好者容易补过头,蛋白粉顿顿不落,日常还要额外狂吃肉,这早就超出了身体的吸收极限。

There's a more efficient balance between training and protein. A study in the British Journal of Sports Medicine followed 147,000 people over 30 years and found that just 90 to 119 minutes of strength training per week — about the length of two films — was linked to a 13% lower risk of death from any cause and a 19% lower risk of cardiovascular death. 其实,想增肌防衰,运动量和蛋白质之间有个更划算的平衡点。《英国运动医学杂志》(BJSM)追踪了 14.7 万人长达 30 年的数据,发现每周只要进行 90 到 119 分钟的力量训练(大概也就是两场电影的时间),全因死亡风险就能降低 13%,心血管疾病死亡风险降低 19%。

For most people, going to the gym once or twice a week and having a sensible amount of good-quality protein afterward is enough for muscle recovery. There's no need to stuff yourself. 对于咱们普通健身爱好者来说,每周去一两趟健身房,练完适量补点优质蛋白就足够肌肉恢复了,没必要把自己塞撑。

Buying protein powder for your parents? Watch for indigestion给爸妈疯狂囤蛋白粉?小心他们消化不良

Muscle mass does decline with age — the medical term is sarcopenia. Out of genuine care, a lot of adult children buy their parents concentrated protein powders, or push them to eat more meat every day. 年纪大了,肌肉确实会自然流失,也就是医学上常说的"肌少症"。很多晚辈出于孝心,给长辈买各种高浓度蛋白粉,或者天天逼着老人多吃肉。

But digestion, kidney function and the body's ability to build muscle all slow down with age. A sudden load of meat or concentrated powder often leads to bloating, constipation and indigestion instead. 但老人的肠胃、肾脏和肌肉合成能力都在退化。突然塞进去一堆肉或者高浓度蛋白粉,他们很容易胃胀、便秘甚至消化不良,身体反而受罪。

A long-term study in Science Advances found that simply keeping a healthy, balanced everyday diet meaningfully extends life for middle-aged and older adults — an average of 1.9 to 3 additional years for men and 1.5 to 2.3 years for women, measured from age 45. 《科学进展》(Science Advances)发表过一项长期研究,只要保持健康、均衡的日常饮食,中老年人的寿命就能明显延长(45 岁时,男性平均能多活 1.9 到 3 年,女性多活 1.5 到 2.3 年)。

So go gently. Slow-cooked tender meat, tofu, steamed fish, eggs and skinless chicken are easy to digest and are high-quality protein — usually a better fit than an industrial supplement. 所以,给长辈补营养得温和点。把肉炖得软烂一些,多选豆腐、清蒸鱼、鸡蛋和去皮鸡肉这类容易消化的优质蛋白,比吃那些工业加工的蛋白粉管用得多。

Two common protein myths关于蛋白质的两个常见误区

"Can I live on protein powder and skip real meals?"天天冲蛋白粉,能不吃肉和菜吗?

No. Protein powder is a patch, not a replacement for food. Fish gives you omega-3s, tofu gives you fibre, egg yolks give you micronutrients — none of which powder provides. Your metabolism relies on whole foods working together. Unless you're genuinely too busy to eat or training at an elite level, three balanced meals a day is still the better answer. 真不行。蛋白粉只是个"补丁",代替不了真正的饭菜。鱼肉里有 Omega-3 脂肪酸,豆腐里有膳食纤维,蛋黄里有各种微量元素,这些是蛋白粉提供不了的。只有真食物在身体里协同作战,代谢系统才能正常转。除非你忙得连吃饭时间都没有,或者运动量大到惊人,否则老老实实吃一日三餐才是首选。

"Is eating high protein a shortcut to weight loss?"靠多吃蛋白质减肥,靠谱吗?

Protein does keep you full longer, which can help you eat less overall — but it still contains calories. Weight loss comes down to a calorie deficit. If you don't move more or cut back elsewhere, simply adding chicken breast or boiled eggs on top of what you already eat will put weight on, not take it off. 虽然蛋白质饱腹感强,能让你少吃点别的,但它本身也是有热量的。减肥说到底看的是热量缺口。如果你不运动,也不减少其他食物的摄入,只是单纯在食谱里多加几块鸡胸肉或两个水煮蛋,最后一样会变胖。

How to tell whether you've got it right怎么知道自己蛋白质吃得对不对?

For healthy adults, a reasonable baseline is about 0.8 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight — roughly 50 grams a day for someone weighing 60 kg. 普通健康成年人,每天大概每公斤体重吃 0.8 克蛋白质就够了(比如一个 60 公斤的人,一天吃 50 克左右)。

But bodies, training habits and kidney health all differ, and weighing every meal is exhausting. A regular check-up is a far easier way to see whether your body is carrying too much. These are the numbers worth looking at: 不过,每个人的体质、运动习惯和肾脏状况都不一样,天天拿着食物秤斤斤计较太累人。其实定期去体检,看看下面这几个关键指标,身体有没有超载一目了然:

What to check检查指标 What it tells you说明什么
Serum creatinine血肌酐 A waste product from muscle breakdown. A high reading often means the kidneys are working hard to clear it.肌肉代谢的废物。要是这个指标偏高,通常说明肾脏排泄得有点吃力了。
Blood urea nitrogen (BUN)尿素氮(BUN) The byproduct of digesting protein. It climbs when you eat a lot of meat, or when the kidneys filter more slowly.蛋白质消化后的"尾气"。如果肉吃太多,或者肾脏过滤效率变慢,这个指标就会往上窜。
Urinalysis尿常规 Watch for protein in the urine. Healthy urine shouldn't contain any — a "+" suggests the kidneys' filter may be under strain.重点看"尿蛋白"。正常人的尿里不应该有蛋白质,要是查出加号("+"),说明肾脏的过滤网可能受损了。
Body composition analysis人体成分分析 Measures body fat and muscle, so you can see whether what you're eating is becoming muscle or fat.也就是测体脂和肌肉,能帮你看看吃进去的营养到底变成了结实的肌肉,还是堆成了脂肪。

If you want a clear picture of your metabolic and kidney health, Careby's Body Check screening through partner clinics can be built around what you actually need — so you're working from real numbers rather than guesswork. And because diet and exercise involve baseline metabolism, hormones and long-standing habits, Careby's partner medical platforms also offer one-on-one physician assessment and a personalized weight management plan. 如果你想彻底摸清自己的代谢和肾脏底细,可以关注康伴合作机构的深度体检套餐,里面的项目都可以根据你的身体情况自由组合,用精准的数据说话,省得自己瞎猜。另外,管住嘴、迈开腿这事涉及基础代谢、内分泌和生活习惯,挺复杂的。康伴合作的专业医疗平台也提供一对一的医生评估和个性化体重管理,跟着专业人士的指导来,总比自己瞎琢磨靠谱。

Common questions常见问题

How much protein do I actually need each day?我每天到底该吃多少蛋白质?
For a healthy adult, about 0.8 grams per kilogram of body weight is a reasonable baseline — roughly 50 grams a day at 60 kg. People doing regular strength training generally need more, around 1.2 to 1.6 g/kg. Your own number depends on your activity level, age and kidney health, so treat these as starting points rather than rules.普通健康成年人,大约每公斤体重 0.8 克是合理的基准——60 公斤的人一天约 50 克。经常做力量训练的人通常需要更多,约每公斤体重 1.2 到 1.6 克。具体数字要看你的活动量、年龄和肾脏状况,以上只是参考起点。
Can I live on protein powder and skip real meals?天天冲蛋白粉,能不吃肉和菜吗?
No. Protein powder is a supplement, not a replacement. Fish provides omega-3s, tofu provides fibre, egg yolks provide micronutrients — powder provides none of these. Unless you're too busy to eat or training at an elite level, three balanced meals a day works better.真不行。蛋白粉只是补充,代替不了真正的饭菜。鱼肉里有 Omega-3,豆腐里有膳食纤维,蛋黄里有各种微量元素,这些蛋白粉都提供不了。除非你忙得没时间吃饭,或者运动量大到惊人,否则一日三餐更靠谱。
Will eating more protein help me lose weight?靠多吃蛋白质减肥,靠谱吗?
Protein keeps you full longer, which can help you eat less overall — but it still has calories. Weight loss comes down to a calorie deficit. Adding chicken breast or boiled eggs on top of what you already eat, without moving more or cutting back elsewhere, will add weight rather than take it off.蛋白质饱腹感强,能让你少吃点别的,但它本身也有热量。减肥归根到底看热量缺口。如果不运动、也不减少其他食物,只是在食谱里多加鸡胸肉或水煮蛋,最后一样会变胖。
Should I buy protein powder for my parents?该给爸妈买蛋白粉吗?
Older adults do lose muscle, but their digestion, kidney function and muscle-building capacity all slow down too. A sudden load of concentrated powder or meat often causes bloating, constipation and indigestion. Tender slow-cooked meat, tofu, steamed fish, eggs and skinless chicken are usually a better fit. If you're unsure, ask a physician first.长辈确实会流失肌肉,但他们的肠胃、肾脏和肌肉合成能力也都在退化。突然塞进大量高浓度蛋白粉或肉类,往往会胃胀、便秘、消化不良。炖得软烂的肉、豆腐、清蒸鱼、鸡蛋和去皮鸡肉通常更合适。如果不确定,建议先咨询医生。

Finding your natural rhythm找回生活原本的节奏

The body is a complex system, and expecting a couple of tubs of protein powder or endless chicken breast to solve everything makes health sound simpler than it is. Sleeping well, keeping stress down and moving regularly do far more for you than worrying about a missed shake. Eat balanced meals, keep a steady routine, get checked from time to time — it's the plainest approach, and it works. 说到底,身体是个复杂的系统,指望靠一两桶蛋白粉或者顿顿鸡胸肉就包治百病,确实把健康想得太简单了。好好睡觉、别太焦虑、适度动一动,这些对健康的益处,比纠结"今天是不是少喝了一杯蛋白粉"大得多。均衡吃饭,规律作息,定期去体检,这才是最朴素也最管用的生活方式。

Stop guessing — look at your actual numbers别再猜了,看看你的真实数据

A Body Check screening through Careby's partner clinics can show how your kidneys, metabolism and body composition are really doing — built around what you need to know. 通过康伴合作机构的深度体检,看清自己的肾脏、代谢与身体成分状况——项目可按您的需要自由组合。

Explore Body Check →了解深度体检 →
Link copied链接已复制
Careby
Rachel LRachel L
Rachel writes Careby's plain-language health guides. Careby helps Canadian families reach doctors faster, understand their health, and coordinate care at home — with support in English and Chinese throughout. Rachel 撰写康伴的通俗健康科普内容。康伴帮助加拿大家庭更快看上医生、读懂自己的健康,并统筹居家护理——全程提供中英双语支持。
Disclaimer:免责声明: This article is general health education only. It is not medical advice, a diagnosis or a treatment plan. If you are making significant changes to your diet, or you have questions about your kidney function or any other aspect of your health, please consult a licensed healthcare professional. 本文仅为一般健康科普,不构成医疗建议、诊断或治疗方案。如果您打算对饮食做出重大调整,或对肾功能及其他健康状况有疑问,请咨询持牌医疗专业人员。
Talk to a real doctor →今日预约医生 →